Imacow's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Just Eat It]

Good

-Good-
The graphics and animation were good in the flash. I've never heard this song before so I don't know how the rest goes. I liked when Al was falling into the portal thingy.

-Bad-
I didn't like how you gave some objects a semi-transparent color job, I've never come across a transparent guitar, or shirt. As Milinko suggested you should of animated more of the song.

-Overall-
A good flash, but you realy should have animated more into the song.

~Review Request Club~

[American Pie]

Meh

-Good-
I like the scribbly shading you did in the BG. Animating the entire song was a good idea, but you just had one angle.

-Bad-
Only animating one angle made it seem like a loop. The animation was alright but the guitar plucking looked sloppy.

-Overall-
Not your best work.

IZSBHR responds:

OK.

[400000?!]

Hmm

Turns out that if I didn't submit flash, you would of been 400018... Im sorry =(

-Good-
The concept was kindof intresting, but it was still predictable. The ending was somewhat funny. At first I thought this was one of your "Achivment movies".

-Bad-
Could of been longer I guess.

-Overall-
A pretty good movie.

~Review Request Club~

kinggila responds:

It could've been an achievement movie if I was up at the right time.

[Chinese New Year 2008]

Well done

-Good-
The graphics in this flash was good. The song was alright although not that enjoyable if you don't understand Chinese, the subtitles were definitly nessesary. The animation synced up with the lyrics well.

-Bad-
This was a realy repeditive flash. The lyrics repeated alot and you repeated alot of the animation. This realy made this unfun to watch the entire flash.

-Overall-
A well done flash but realy repeditive.

~Review Request Club~

[We don't really even care]

Alright

-Good-
The animation was good for the most part in this. The guitar was good, but it looked wierd without her having arms considering she does in the show. The graphics were pretty good but could of looked more like they do in Zim.

-Bad-
Well the background and music could of been of higher quality. Also the unsinced lips made it seem unrealistic in a movie like this.

-Overall-
An alright movie but could of been better.

~Review Request Club~

IZSBHR responds:

SHE HAD ARMS IN IT!

[Edgar N' Locke 03]

Pretty good

-Good-
A pretty good sotryline here. The ending was a suprise considering these episodes have been mostly discussions. The VA was good as usualy.

-Bad-
Well, this episode was pretty bland as it was mostly just talking until the end. You could of had the background face and have Gau singing and dancing on a stage etc.

-Overall-
A pretty good movie

~Review Request Club~

kinggila responds:

"The ending was a suprise considering these episodes have been mostly discussions."

Well, Edgar and Locke tried to kill Gogo on the second episode. :P

[Stick and Stick Episode 4]

Alright

-Good-
There was a little humor in this flash but there could of been more considering you're focusing on humor with this series. The graphics were decent for what you're doing with this series. The music was pretty good.

-Bad-
Well I thought this flash could have been funnier. Also one of the text blurbs wasn't onscreen long enough to be read completely.

-Overall-
A decen't addition to the series.

~Review Request Club~

[Jim and Pals Shorts: Ep 3]

Alright

-Good-
The graphics were pretty good in this flash, the background is better then your usual ones. There was a spec of humor, but I only chuckled but still a decent one.

-Bad-
Well the fact of having no voice acting realy draws away for this type of flash. I would like to see you try and experiment with Jim and try and add VA and some arms, you know just to try it out.

-Overall-
Pretty funny, but I woulden't think "Jim flashes" are a good fit for this type of flash.

~Review Request Club~

Jimtopia responds:

Weird that you wouldn't think that Jim is meant for this type of flash, because this type of flash was the only thing I made when I first started out. Also, I am going to be doing a voiced cartoon soon. You'll see...

[Stick and Stick Episode 3]

Pretty good

-Good-
The graphics weren't that good in this flash, but I assume it was more about humor then graphics and animation. This was was pretty funny. I liked the music. The animated fight was alright, but it was short and hard to tell what was happening.

-Bad-
Well like I said, the fight scene could of been longer and more dramatic and the graphics weren't that detailed.

-Overall-
a pretty funny flash

~Review Request Club~

Lost-Wisdom responds:

Yeah, the graphics were bad at best. But I was surprised you found my humor funny. Still, kudos for that. I'm glad you liked the music and yes, the animated fight was a bit horrible. Who I'm I kidding, the animated scene was a killer for me, I can't seem to make animations right.

Thanks for a honest review though, thanks.

[Phoenix Wrong: Epic Turn]

Pretty good

-Good-
There was alot of humor in this, I laughed at a bunch of the clips. The sprites were well done for the most part although I would of liked to see some drawn stuff.

-Bad-
Like I said some of the clips were funny, some weren't that funny. Also the Phoenix Wrong craze is kinda old now.

-Overall-
A pretty good flash

IZSBHR responds:

If I made one at the height of the craze, people will tell me that I'm cheating NG. Now I can show that this honestly got its score, and I did create some of my own in it. The one with P & M making out had a custom made sprite in it.