Imacow's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Luis is an Animator...]

Hah

-Good-
I found the idea of this funny. I liked how you had Luis' awards and it seemed like an endless list. The graphics were funny and so was that great song.

-Bad-
The graphics could have been improved but as you said you had to whip this up fast. But the graphics added to the humor.

-Overall-
A funny flash

~Review Request Club~

LuckyLollipopLad responds:

Glad you liked!

The song was all recorded within the 1h 20mins!

Stay funky,
- Bez

[Sherbert the Cat 3-1]

Good episode

-Good-
I liked the reflection effectsused on the shiny button thingy aswell on the window in the store. The music was a decent choice. The animation was pretty good also.

-Bad-
One thing I didn't realy like was that when Sherbert's walking, his legs only go back and forth. You could have made a more complex walk cycle.

-Overall-
A good additon

~Review Request Club~

Jonimator responds:

Thanks for the review. I'm working on his wakling for the 4th episode now. Glad you liked it.

[The Snowball Cartoon]

Good

-Good-
I definitly perfered the graphics used in this one to your other one I just reviewed. The backgrounds were done well and the animation was done better also. The music was a good choice once again and seemed to go well with the movie.

-Bad-
The only real thing I didn't like was the snow in the background. I think it went to fast and didn't repeat right.

-Overall-
Well done

~Review Request Club~

Jimtopia responds:

Ah, well thank you, man I love the RRC! :D

[Jimtopia Changes]

Decent

-Good-
The music playing in the background throughout this flash was a good choice for a movie like this. There was some humor throughout this movie aswell.

-Bad-
The main flaw of this movie would definitly be its artwork and animation. There also could have been some voice acting insted of text clouds.

-Overall-
An okay movie but needs more.

~Review Request Club~

Jimtopia responds:

Well, don't worry, from now on I am animating at 24 FPS and am doing backgrounds.

Anyway, thx for reviewing!

[The Building]

Pretty good

-Good-
The art was okay in this collab. Some were good some were horible. One of them was so strange it messed up the whole foundation of the building. The music choice was pretty good although it took a long time to repeat when it was over. Another good thing was that it had a pause button for when I had to read realy long text boxes while the screen was scrolling(Esko-Man).

-Bad-
The main thing that was wrong with this flash was that everyones building had a different length. You should of stated a basic width and height of your building so that this woulden't of happened. The only other main thing that I didn't like about this was that people kept doing the same thing over and over again. Their was about 4 holes in the side of the building and 2 or 3 Clock HQ's. Then their was about 15 people doing stick figures shooting up the place.

-Overall-
A pretty good flash but was rought around the edges.

Siggles responds:

you made some good points, thanks for that :)

[Sherbert the Cat 2]

Good

-Good-
The graphics were done well in this flash although I think you should of redrawn some of the pictures you used(Like the tank logo etc.). The music was definitly a strong point in this flash. There was a little humor in this movie. My favorite being when you see the cat using google.

-Bad-
I would of realy liked to see more sound effects in this flash. Alot of cartoony sounds would have went great with this.

-Overall-
A good flash. Nice work.

~Review Request Club~

[Duck Luck Intro. (Old)]

Good intro

-Good-
Your characters were drawn rather well. The short animations you had for them were well done aswell. The animation was smooth and good. The music choice was a nice one. I think it was a good choice for an intro like this. You also had some nice effects. I enjoyed the scrolling film scroll.

-Bad-
The only thing that was realy bad was that the pictures inside the film scroll's quality wasn't the best and looked stranne.

-Overall-
A great intro.

~Review Request Club~

[Clay Killer]

Meh

-Good-
The animation was very smooth in this claymation. You had some nice walkcycles etc. It would of been nice if you have had the chainsaw animated.

-Bad-
This would of been alot better with some sound effects. You realy only needed a chainsaw sound and a screaming one.

-Overall-
Good claymation but doesn't look or feel complete.

~Review Request Club~