Imacow's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Monek]

An improvement

-GOOD-
The graphics were done well in this. Characters were done nice and so were the backgrounds. The animation was done decently but the "Rayman" arms and legs aren't my favorite.

-BAD-
Well once again I wasn't to fond of the voice acting. They were very squeeky and sounded wrong.

-OVERALL-
An okay movie, some ofn the "Ministories" were funny others weren't.

~Review Request Club~

[VT - East Park]

Meh

-GOOD-
I liked the artwork on the 4 main characters. I liked the fact that you had voice acting. Most flashes just have a nice text box next to the character. Either way the voice acting wasn't that good and didn't sound like the characters from South Park at all.

-BAD-
WEl the animation wasn't the best in this flash. One thing that bugged my was layers. At random times characters would run and just go under objects like doors. The walk cycles were realy just the characters tilting from side to side. Another thing was the syncing. You had a 4 frame loop of difrent mount positions. Another thing that bugged was the fact that you put random songs that don't realy go or sound good with the flash.

-OVERALL-
A good idea but you need alot of work.

~Review Request Club~

[A Newgrounds X-mas Story]

Decent

-GOOD-
The graphics were okay in this movie, Although it realy looks like you rushed the graphics. Your objects were very 2-D and could have been more realistic. Another thing was that I didn't like how you took images and pasted them into your flash. It looked bad and didn't blend with the rest of your movie. The sound was done quite nicly in this flash but I didn't like the sharp stops and silent intervals between songs.

-BAD-
Well the animation wasn't my favorite part of this flash. One thing I like to do when working with characters without arms is to add stick arms and legs to make it look better. Like I said before you could of worked on the overal presentation of this flash.

-OVERALL-
An okay flash but needs touching up.

~Review Request Club~

Dash-02 responds:

Thanks, I understand that I need to practice on my graphics's but I had a limited amount of time. As for the sound I don't know how to fade it out It could have been better I understand but you have to give me credit it passed with a decent score and thanks a lot for your review It will help me on my next flash.

[Declaration of Revocation]

meh

-GOOD-
Well I supose some of this stuff would be funny if I wasn't American so it had some humor I guess. You had some pretty good points about Americas goverment witch everyone can laugh at. The music playing in the background was pretty funny.

-BAD-
Well most of the stuff you said that would be true in England aren't realy in America. The graphics and animation weren't realy the highlight of the flash. I asume you were focusing on the jokes?

-OVERALL-
A SoSo flash, has ups and downs.

~REview Request Club~

Sidorio responds:

You're right about focusing on jokes, I can't do animation at all.

[Ghost Vision]

Good one

-GOOD-
The Graphics were done well in this flash. The menu was nice and the scene select was a good feature considering the flash was pretty long. One thing I enjoyed about this flash was that there was always something going on in the background.

-BAD-
Well one thing I noticed was that you were a little scimpy on te animation. You realy didn't see the main character do a real walk cycle one time. the only other thing was that I didn't find that the voice acting was very "Anime-ish".

-OVERALL-
A great flash.

~Review Request Club~

[SM-Bring it all Back]

Suprisingly Great

-GOOD-
This was a big change from your guys last movie. Your last one was gloomy and shit but this is happy and fun. I loved the graphics and how everything was bouncing. The artwork was good and I loved the backgrounds. The music was great and went with the flash.

-BAD-
Well I was watching this nfun flash and all of a sudden it ended... FINISH IT!

-OVERALL-
I love it but make sure to finish it.

~Review Request Club~

RampageSun responds:

Thanks for your honest review yes it is unfinnished and It will be done dont worrie sorry for the short ending on this.
~RampageClock~

[Textual Adventures II]

meh

-GOOD-
The music you picked out for this was pretty good. I also liked the text you used for the characters and whatnot.

-BAD-
Well this flash realy wasn't that interesting. I think you could of put more into this like voice acting and some better backgrounds.

-OVERALL-
Needs some work

~Review Request Club~

Frenzy responds:

Thanks

~ Z

[A Bahamut's Xmas Tale]

Good

-GOOD-
Well I found this flash pretty funny. Graham was pretty funny even though Im not familar with him and all of your inside jokes. The voice acting was pretty good and it was fun to see all the characters from your other flashes come together (even though they didn't look particualy good on the tree.) I also laughed when Afro_Stud was ontop of the tree.

-BAD-
Well I didn't realy think the animation was done very well. Like when Satan and Graham get thrown out.

-OVERALL-
A good, funny flash.

~Rview Request Club~

kinggila responds:

You can see a picture of that christmas tree from my deviantART with Afro on top of the tree. :P

[SM:SunMafiaIntro (Undone)]

Decent

-GOOD-
Well the main graphics such as graphics for characters were done pretty well although I noticed some of the backgrounds needed some work. The music was suprisingly good. It seemed to go with the flash well.

-BAD-
one thing I didn't likle was the huge "Join Us" in the top of the screen. It seemed more of a blockaid then an add. A simple one in the bottom right-hand corner would be fine. Other then the tank, the animation wasn't to interesting. I would of sugested using stick legs.

-OVERALL-
An Okay movie but room for improvment.

~Review Request Club~

RaspberrySun responds:

ok... the join us is supposed to be there,if not.. no one will see it. or join :P

[The Tape]

Okay movie

-GOOD-
The graphics were satisfactory although it realy shows that you made this in one night. I kinda enjoyed how you tryed to make it look as if you are the person dropping the change on the counter although it looked more as if you were looking though a telescope then through the viewers eyes.

-BAD-
Like I said before this realy looks like you skimped out of this and did it in a short period of time. The animation in this wasn't particuly great (mostly in the change dropping part). I didn't realy like how you used real picutres and static for the movie. It didn't look very good contrasting with the backgrounds.

-OVERALL-
An okay movie but you should of worked harder on this.

boner118 responds:

Thank you very much for the fab review. It's good to have a review that you can actually work from. You'll have to excuse the drawings (I am a terrible drawer (even the good ones took ages (that mutilated dude halfway through the tape took like an hour to get right).

Sorry about the eye thing (I didn't know how to make the shape, as if you think when you look there are no borders). I went for one long oval instead of two joined circles, but ye, as you said it looks like a telescope (it's exactly what my brother said).

Thanks