Score: 6

"Got a laugh out of it"

submission: Spread His Wings

date: July 21, 2009

-Good-
The art and animation were pretty well done here. The music was a pretty good choice too. The voice acting was good and the ending made me laugh.

-Bad-
Not too much here, overall pretty well done.

-Overall-
A nice little movie, pretty funny.

~Review Request Club

Score: 3

"Could use work"

submission: The Amazing Tom

date: July 21, 2009

-Good-
The music for the part where the cat was skateboarding wasn't a bad choice. You could have added different music for the different tricks to make this look better.

-Bad-
Well most of the animation were poorly done tweens. You took most of the graphics from images and I thought the words were a little too hard to read.

You could have sped up most of the tricks to make them look more realistic/funny, they look unrealistic and badly done as they are now.

~Review Request Club

Score: 5

"Alright"

submission: TNEJ (art collab)

date: July 6, 2009

-Good-
I did like a decent amount of the drawings here. I liked the story at the beginning with the construction zone, but I thought the story went off too far from the original. I guess that's destined to happen in this type of thing though.

-Bad-
Well my main problem with this was the main layout. I think you should have increased the size of the flash document and the images themselves. A lot of the images were too small and distorted to even try to read.

Another thing was that characters seemed to appear and disappear at random. A perfect example is the Russian war veteran who appeared for two frames and was never explained. Another would be the construction workers reuniting in Paris.

-Overall-
Overall this was decent, I enjoyed it at some points. Other parts just confused me.

~Review Request Club

Score: 4

"Hmm"

submission: Billy Mays: A Tribute

date: June 29, 2009

-Good-
I liked the music choice for this flash, it was a nice tune. The little biography at the beginning was a nice addition if you were unsure of who he was.

-Bad-
Well, there's nothing here really separating this from other tributes, it was really just some images and music. Maybe you could have added some animation to go with the pictures or something.

-Overall-
A nice little tribute but nothing too new.

~Review Request Club

Score: 6

"Pretty nice trailor"

submission: BTS 2 - Trailer

date: June 28, 2009

-Good-
I liked the preloader you had here. The static and the door opening were pretty cool. I got a few laughs out of the movie, such as when he was holding the camera while driving and grabbing his balls or whatever. The "attractions" of the movie made me laugh.

-Bad-
It seemed some of the clips were kinda blurry, particularly the one where he was running.

-Overall-
A cool little tailor, it does it's job in getting people interested.

~Review Request Club

Score: 4

"Alright"

submission: Tribute to Tributes

date: June 26, 2009

-Good-
Not too bad as far as tributes go I suppose. The beginning where you didn't know the date was pretty funny. A nice little rant, I kinda agree with it.

-Bad-
Well it was kinda short, and seemed kinda made up on the spot.

-Overall-
A decent little movie, pretty short though.

~Review Request Club

Score: 8

"Nice job"

submission: -8bit Clouds- Collab

date: June 24, 2009

-Good-
I was eager to see this collab come out. I thought the song was great and a good one to base this on. I liked how everyone used the pixel tool. Some of them turned out really good. The little preloader game was a nice addition but the movie was loaded for me before I even noticed the button.

-Bad-
I noticed on the ending menu that one of the authors is not shown unless you actually highlight the text and drag down with your mouse.

-Overall-
A cool collab, nice work.

~Review Request Club

Score: 7

"Nice"

submission: WALK!

date: June 24, 2009

-Good-
Another nice collab. I thought all the parts were good all around. Some were funny and some were very detailed. I personally liked the car and the alien guy walking backwards. The music was a cool choice.

-Bad-
Once again, no music on the menu. I think it would lighten it up a bit.

I was a bit confused as to what happened after all the cycles were showed once, as they seemed to continue in a random pattern.

-Overall-
A nice collab, good job.

~Review Request Club

Score: 7

"Hah, pretty nice"

submission: DANCE!!

date: June 24, 2009

-Good-
This seemed like a nice little collab. I thought some of the loops here were pretty funny. I thought all of the dances were pretty well done. I liked the simple background portal thingy.

-Bad-
I thought you could have added some music to the menu to lighten it up a bit.

-Overall-
A nicely done collaboration.

~Review Request Club

Score: 6

"Pretty good"

submission: Headlights On Dark Roads

date: June 24, 2009

-Good-
I thought the song selection was good, an interesting song to animate. The graphics and animation were pretty well done, I liked some of your backgrounds but some of your character animations seemed a little rushed. You could have fixed up some of your brushstrokes a little.

-Bad-
One thing I didn't like was that you reused a lot of the same scenes. This isn't such a problem but I thought you did it a little too much.

-Overall-
A good music video, I liked it.

~Review Request Club